A change from the usual here.
What happens if you spend you life pursuing a dream, only to fail because it was the wrong dream?
I went this evening to see Arthur Miller’s play ‘Death of a Salesman’ at West Yorkshire Playhouse, in which Willy Loman is a man whose dreams never came to pass. He had a dream – but it was very much the wrong one – he seemed to have adopted the dream of another man and taken it for his own, without questioning whether it was right for him.
Perhaps there is a parallel here with Bradford? It is increasingly a city of unfulfilled aspiration.
It’s residents are more likely to want to set up a business than almost anywhere else in the country – but they are less likley to do so.
It’s City fathers built momuments to success that they no doubt thought would last for many generations. If they could but see where the city has been for the last half century.
It’s a city that wants to do the best for it’s children – it invented the school lunch, and today is a city in which no end of education experts invest entire careers on trying to give our children a better chance. Yet today we have some of the least healthy kids in the country and our schools are still fighting to make a difference.
It’s a city with gret potential – diversity is often trotted out as a strength without a lot of thought, but it really is – or rather can be – the reality can be altogether different for many.
It’s a creative city – art, music, literature – Bradfordians are up there with the best, try a night out with University students – they know this.
For all the yorkshire grit it’s a caring city – perhaps because it’s people know life can be hard.
It is a city that wants to succeed, but a city whose ambition remains unfulfilled. The entrepreneurialism of Bradford people is hard to reconcile with streets of vacant, abandoned shops and unloved frontages.
Perhaps that’s because we’ve been aiming for the wrong things. Bradford is often compared (negatively) to Leeds, but it it not Leeds. Leeds is good at being Leeds. Why not let Bradford be good at being Bradford, instead of bad at being Leeds? Of course, we’d need to start seeing our City differently.
The Westfield shopping centre scheme is a good idea – until you look at other cities that have build shopping centres in their city centres – Reading for example, where the shopping centre is an excellent one but still leaves you feeling sometimes that planners left the City’s heart beating but took away it’s soul. Until, also, you look at other places defined by shopping centres – back to Leeds again. Leeds is an attractive proposition for shoppers, as long as you’re looking for the same thing whether you’re in the city centre, the White Rose centre, or indeed other cities – try Meadowhall. A mid-sized shopping centre with a smaller selection of the same stuff will never bring people into Bradford. Nor will it ever be Bradford. It will be better than the mess that was there before, and better than a hole in the ground – but if not aspirational enough, if it does not connect the city together and connect with the city around it, it runs the risk of being the same mistake made in the 1960s when much of horror recently demolished was erected.
Perhaps the current economic crisis provides an opportunity to rethink.
Perhaps it offers a chance for crossrail, perhaps a chance to bring some of the creativity that runs throughout the City into it’s centre. Perhaps an opportunity to reconnect Little Germany with the City Centre. Or perhaps that is a ‘dream to far’, and we need to settle for Westfield, or something like it. If we must we must, but I’d like to think we can do better.
Likewise, the Odeon development – New Victoria Place – will be better than what is there now, as long as you don’t too hard look at which City you’re putting it in to, and where you’re putting it. As soon as you do, the absurdity of it is evident. It takes away an iconic skyline and replaces it with an identikit office block, and one in all the wrong proportions at that. I may have said all along it was the wrong thing to do, and to have voted against it, but still we seem to be stuck with it. Why can’t we have something more suited to Bradford? Something that will complement it’s surroundings and inspire Bradford’s children as the Odeon and Alhambra did? Because Yorkshire Forward says we can’t? Not good enough, our children will say in 20 years time.
The good bit though is the City Park – unpopular though it may be at the moment, it connects the city and offers something unique and special. It will be excellent when complete, giving people a reason to look again at the City Centre, and a reason to enjoy it – a reason to be part of it. It just won’t be enough by itself.
We should have a centre that is distinctly Bradford, a city centre that helps the city understand itself. Most of all we need a city centre that inspires our children.
15 years ago right here in this district a teacher inspired me to read Arthur Miller. I’ve waited those 15 years to see Death of a Salesman – I don’t think I’ve waited quite that long for anything else! I’m glad I did – the performance was well worth the wait, and it is a small part of a dream fulfilled.
But can we do the same for Bradford?